Beyond the ordinary

📍 Edgewater, FL — August 18, 2025

In a bold move that pits local governance against state authority, the Edgewater City Council voted 3-2 Monday night to uphold two controversial development moratoriums, directly defying Florida’s newly enacted Senate Bill 180 (SB 180). The decision came after weeks of public debate, emotional testimony, and mounting pressure from both residents and state officials.

🗳️ The Vote Breakdown
- In favor of keeping the moratoriums: Mayor Diezel Depew, Councilmembers Eric Rainbird and Charlotte Gillis
- Opposed: Councilmembers Mike Thomas and Debbie Dolbow

The ordinances in question include:
- A ban on building permits in the Florida Shores Drainage Basin if the project adds impervious surfaces.
- A city-wide pause on annexations, rezonings, site plans, and amendments to zoning agreements and the Comprehensive Plan.

🌊 Why It Matters
Supporters argue the moratoriums are essential for flood mitigation and responsible growth, especially in the wake of recent hurricanes. “We are not ignoring the law—we are protecting our people,” said Councilmember Rainbird, who delivered an impassioned defense of local autonomy. Gillis echoed the sentiment, citing overwhelming public opposition to SB 180.

SB 180, signed by Governor Ron DeSantis in June, prohibits municipalities from regulating development in ways that could hinder post-disaster rebuilding. It mandates the repeal of local ordinances that conflict with its provisions, sparking backlash from cities like Edgewater that see the law as a threat to community safety and environmental resilience.

🗣️ Mayor Diezel Depew Responds
Mayor Depew, who cast the deciding vote, acknowledged the legal risks but stood firm: “We’re not trying to fight Tallahassee—we’re trying to survive. Our residents deserve protection, not politics.” He added that Edgewater is open to dialogue with state officials but will not compromise its values under pressure.

⚖️ The Dissenting View
Councilmembers Thomas and Dolbow warned that defying SB 180 could expose the city to lawsuits and state intervention. “We swore to uphold the law,” Thomas said. “We need to find a way to comply without abandoning our residents.”

📣 Community Reaction
Residents packed the council chambers, many speaking out against SB 180 and urging the council to hold the line. “This is about our homes, our safety, our future,” said one longtime resident. “We’re proud of our council for standing up.”

---

> Disclaimer: This article summarizes a developing legal and political conflict. The Edgewater City Council’s decision to maintain its moratoriums may face legal challenges under Florida law. Readers should note that SB 180 is binding statewide legislation, and its enforcement mechanisms are still unfolding. This report does not constitute legal advice or endorsement of any party’s position.